State Key Laboratory of Simulation and Regulation of Water Cycle in River Basin, China Institute of Water Resources and Hydropower Research, Beijing 100038, China
Abstract：This study analyzes the effects of various turbulence models on the hydrodynamic simulation accuracy and computing time for flow in a complex asymmetric penstock. The turbulence models used here for closure of the Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations were the shear-stress-transport k-ω (SST k-ω), standard k-ε (Sk-ε), realizable k-ε (Rk-ε), renormalization group k-ε (RNG k-ε) and Reynolds stress model (RSM) models. The results show the differences in the velocity, turbulent kinetic energy, and water head loss predictions and the computing times for these five turbulence models. The predictions are compared with experimental data to show that the computing times and the differences between the numerical and experimental results vary with the flow conditions. The RSM results agree best with the experimental results, while the SST k-ω model costs less CPU time. Both the RSM and SST k-ω are found to be appropriate for calculating the hydraulic characteristics of the flow in the complex asymmetric penstock, depending on the available computing resources and the required accuracy. The Sk-ε, Rk-ε and RNG k-ε models all give lower accuracy predictions of the flow distribution, confluence and water head loss.
陈文创, 张蕊, 张文远, 章晋雄, 张东. 复杂非对称岔管数值模拟中湍流模型的影响[J]. 清华大学学报（自然科学版）, 2018, 58(8): 752-760.
CHEN Wenchuang, ZHANG Rui, ZHANG Wenyuan, ZHANG Jinxiong, ZHANG Dong. Effect of turbulence models on the simulation of the flow in a complex asymmetric penstock. Journal of Tsinghua University(Science and Technology), 2018, 58(8): 752-760.
[1] ADAMS K, WUTZKE C A, ARNOLD K, et al. 2017 hydropower status report[R]. London:International Hydropower Association, 2017. [2] 苏凯, 李聪安, 伍鹤皋, 等. 水电站月牙肋钢岔管研究进展综述[J]. 水利学报, 2017, 48(8):968-976.SU K, LI C A, WU H G, et al. Review of the crescent-rib steel bifurcation of hydropower station[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2017, 48(8):968-976. (in Chinese) [3] 李玲, 李玉梁, 黄继汤, 等. 三岔管内水流流动的数值模拟与实验研究[J]. 水利学报, 2001, 32(3):49-53.LI L, LI Y L, HUANG J T, et al. Numerical simulation and experimental study on water flow in Y-type tube[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2001, 32(3):49-53. (in Chinese) [4] 刘沛清, 屈秋林, 王志国, 等. 内加强月牙肋三岔管水力特性数值模拟[J]. 水利学报, 2004, 35(3):42-46.LIU P Q, QU Q L, WANG Z G, et al. Numerical simulation on hydrodynamic characteristics of bifurcation pipe with internal crescent rib[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2004, 35(3):42-46. (in Chinese) [5] 高学平, 张尚华, 韩延成, 等. 引水岔管水力特性三维数值计算[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2005(12):93-97.GAO X P, ZHANG S H, HAN Y C, et al. 3-D numerical simulation of hydraulic characteristics in water diversion bifurcated pipes[J]. China Rural Water & Hydropower, 2005(12):93-97. (in Chinese) [6] 王志国, 陈永兴. 西龙池抽水蓄能电站内加强月牙肋岔管水力特性研究[J]. 水力发电学报, 2007, 26(1):42-47.WANG Z G, CHEN Y X. Study on hydraulic characteristic of Escher-Wyss wyepiece of Xilongchi pumped storage power station[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2007, 26(1):42-47. (in Chinese) [7] 毛根海, 章军军, 程伟平, 等. 卜型岔管水力模型试验及三维数值计算研究[J]. 水力发电学报, 2005, 24(2):16-20, 51.MAO G H, ZHANG J J, CHENG W P, et al. Experimental study and 3-D numerical simulation on water flow in Y-type pipe[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2005, 24(2):16-20, 51. (in Chinese) [8] 戎贵文, 魏文礼, 刘玉玲. 分岔管道三维湍流水力特性数值模拟[J]. 水利学报, 2010, 41(4):398-405.RONG G W, WEI W L, LIU Y L. 3-D numerical simulation for hydraulic characteristics of turbulent flow in bifurcated duct[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2010, 41(4):398-405. (in Chinese) [9] 董壮, 罗龙洪, 郑福寿. 岔管流动的数值模拟[J]. 河海大学学报(自然科学版), 2007, 35(1):14-17.DONG Z, LUO L H, ZHENG F S. Numerical simulation of flow in bifurcated pipes[J]. Journal of Hohai University (Natural Sciences), 2007, 35(1):14-17. (in Chinese) [10] 陈文兵, 孙宏健, 齐央. 非对称三岔管水力特性数值计算与流态分析[J]. 水电能源科学, 2008, 26(5):71-74.CHEN W B, SUN H J, QI Y. Numerical calculation of hydraulic characteristics and analysis of flow state in asymmetric branch pipe[J]. Water Resources & Power, 2008, 26(5):71-74. (in Chinese) [11] 郑源, 严继松, 张占, 等. 抽水蓄能电站引水岔管水力特性数值模拟[J]. 排灌机械, 2008, 26(2):45-48.ZHENG Y, YAN J S, ZHANG Z, et al. Numerical simulation on hydraulic characteristics in water diversion bifurcated pipes of pumped storage power station[J]. Drainage & Irrigation Machinery, 2008, 26(2):45-48. (in Chinese) [12] 梁春光, 程永光. 基于CFD的抽水蓄能电站岔管水力优化[J]. 水力发电学报, 2010, 29(3):84-91.LIANG C G, CHENG Y G. Hydraulic optimization of pipe bifurcation of pumped-storage power station by CFD method[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2010, 29(3):84-91. (in Chinese) [13] 董家, 严根华, 杨兴义, 等. 月牙肋岔管群水力损失模型试验与数值模拟结果的比较[J]. 水电能源科学, 2016, 34(10):60-64.DONG J, YAN G H, YANG X Y, et al. Experimental research and numerical simulation comparison of unsymmetrical Y-type penstock for hydraulic loss[J]. Water Resources & Power, 2016, 34(10):60-64. (in Chinese) [14] LAUNDER B E, SPALDING D B. Lectures in mathematical models of turbulence[M]. London:Academic Press, 1972. [15] SHIH T H, LIOU W W, SHABBIR A, et al. A new k-εeddy viscosity model for high Reynolds number turbulent flows[J]. Computers & Fluids, 1995, 24(3):227-238. [16] YAKHOT V, ORSZAG S A. Renormalization group analysis of turbulence I:Basic theory[J]. Journal of Scientific Computing, 1986, 1(1):3-51. [17] MENTER F, KUNTZ M, LANGTRY R. Ten years of industrial experience with the SST turbulence model[J]. Turbulence, Heat and Mass Transfer, 2003, 4(1):625-632. [18] LAUNDER B E, REECE G J, RODI W. Progress in the development of a Reynolds-stress turbulence closure[J]. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1975, 68(3):537-566. [19] 张文远. 某抽水蓄能电站钢筋混凝土高压岔管水力学特性研究物理模型试验[R]. 北京:中国水利水电科学研究院, 2017.ZHANG W Y. Experimental study on the hydraulic characteristics of a concrete penstock in a pumped-storage hydroelectric plant[R]. Beijing:China Institute of Water Resources and Hydropower Research, 2017. (in Chinese) [20] 李玉梁, 李玲, 陈嘉范, 等. 抽水蓄能电站对称岔管的流动阻力特性[J]. 清华大学学报(自然科学版), 2003, 43(2):270-272, 280.LI Y L, LI L, CHEN J F, et al. Flow resistance characteristics of symmetric fork tube used in a storage-pumped hydroelectric plant[J]. Journal of Tsinghua University (Science and Technology), 2003, 43(2):270-272, 280. (in Chinese) [21] 李玲, 陆豪, 陈嘉范. 抽水蓄能电站尾水岔管水流运动及阻力特性试验研究[J]. 水力发电学报, 2008, 27(3):101-104, 109.LI L, LU H, CHEN J F. Experimental research on current resistant characteristics of tail water fork tube in the pumped-storage hydroelectric plant[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2008, 27(3):101-104, 109. (in Chinese)
2018, Vol. 58 
