科学配备消防装备、提升灾害事故现场风险评估能力是减少消防员伤亡事故的重要手段。为深入剖析火灾环境下“热源-服装-人体”系统的传热机制,提高服装对消防员的职业防护,该文基于燃烧假人系统和计算流体动力学原理,建立了“火灾环境-防护服-人体”三维传热模型,定量分析了火场热流密度、热暴露时间、服装厚度和服装表面发射率4个因素对人体表面皮肤烧伤比例和分布的作用机制。模拟计算结果表明:服装因素对烧伤比例的影响与处在火灾中心的着装人体表面传热方式和人体皮肤厚度分布相关;消防服设计方面需优化开口结构设计,以降低颈部、小臂和小腿的烧伤比例。
[Objective] Firefighting gear serves as a crucial barrier for firefighters to prevent skin burns and reduce life-threatening risks during fire emergencies. Scientifically equipping firefighters with appropriate gear and enhancing the capability to assess on-site risk of disaster incidents are crucial for reducing casualties among firefighters. During a fire, the core of the heat transfer process revolves around the system of environment, clothing, and human body. A comprehensive analysis of the heat transfer mechanisms of the system is a scientific approach to improve the thermal protection level of the human body. This study aims to reveal the heat transfer mechanisms of the clothed human body to enhance occupational protection for firefighters.[Methods] The flame manikin system was employed in physical experiments to establish and validate numerical models. A geometric model of the combustion chamber with a clothed human body was established using a three-dimensional body scanner and reverse engineering technology. The turbulence, combustion, and radiation models were determined based on combustion chamber characteristics. The initial conditions, boundary conditions, and solution methods for the model were determined to calculate the system's heat transfer process. A skin heat transfer model with actual skin thickness was developed to predict skin burns. This model was combined with the flame manikin model to conduct virtual flame manikin tests under various thermal conditions. The fire environment and clothing are crucial elements in human thermal protection research. Herein, heat flux intensity and heat exposure duration were selected as environmental factors. Clothing thickness and surface emissivity were selected as clothing factors. All factors were set at nine levels, and a four-factor, nine-level orthogonal experimental design was used with 81 simulation calculations.[Results] The results of the simulation research indicate the followings. (1) The increase in heat flux intensity has the most substantial impact on the proportion of skin burns. (2) The proportion of skin burns generally increases with the increase in heat exposure duration. When the heat exposure duration is long, burn injuries tend to concentrate on the upper body because of the accumulation and increase in hot airflow. (3) With the increase in clothing thickness, the variation in the proportion of first-degree burns on the body's skin surface exhibits fluctuations. The proportion of second-degree burns considerably decreases between clothing thickness levels 1 and 3. (4) No clear pattern was observed in the proportions of skin burns with increasing clothing surface emissivity.[Conclusions] Determining a safe working distance or safe working time is important for the occupational safety of firefighters. The impact of clothing factors on burn proportions differs from the results of fabric studies. In the clothed state, different angles between the local body surface and heat source affect the actual incident heat flux on the clothing surface. Systematic analysis of burn degree distribution reveals that body areas with clothing openings, such as the neck, forearm, and calf, are the most susceptible to burns. Enhancing the design of clothing openings and improving the thermal protective performance of firefighter gear can benefit firefighters.
[1] TORVI D A, HADJISOPHOCLEUS G V. Research in protective clothing for firefighters:State of the art and future directions[J]. Fire Technology, 1999, 35(2):111-130.
[2] LINN R R, CUNNINGHAM P. Numerical simulations of grass fires using a coupled atmosphere-fire model:Basic fire behavior and dependence on wind speed[J]. Journal of Geophysical Research:Atmospheres, 2005, 110(110):D13107.
[3] MAH T, SONG G W. Investigation of the contribution of garment design to thermal protection. Part 2:Instrumented female mannequin flash-fire evaluation system[J]. Textile Research Journal, 2010, 80(14):1473-1487.
[4] LI S, SPOON J, GREER J T, et al. Flame resistant textiles for flash fires[M]//KILINC F S. Handbook of fire resistant textiles. Amsterdam:Elsevier, 2013:501-519.
[5] ROSSI R M, SCHMID M, CAMENZIND M A. Thermal energy transfer through heat protective clothing during a flame engulfment test[J]. Textile Research Journal, 2014, 84(13):1451-1460.
[6] TIAN M, WANG Z L, LI J. 3D numerical simulation of heat transfer through simplified protective clothing during fire exposure by CFD[J]. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2016, 93:314-321.
[7] TIAN M, LI J. Heat transfer modeling within the microclimate between 3D human body and clothing:Effects of ventilation openings and fire intensity[J]. International Journal of Clothing Science and Technology, 2021, 33(4):542-561.
[8] TIAN M, LI J. A method to predict burn injuries of firefighters considering heterogeneous skin thickness distribution based on the instrumented manikin system[J]. International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics, 2021, 27(4):1166-1178.
[9] STOLL A M, CHIANTA M A. Method and rating system for evaluation of thermal protection[J]. Aerospace Medicine, 1969, 40(11):1232-1238.
[10] TIAN M, LI J. 3D heat transfer modeling and parametric study of a human body wearing thermal protective clothing exposed to flash fire[J]. Fire and Materials, 2018, 42(6):657-667.
[11] ABBOTT N J, SCHULMAN S. Protection from fire:Nonflammable clothing:A review[J]. Fire Technology, 1976, 12(3):204-218.
[12] CAMERON S E, D'ANGELO P A, AUERBACH M A, et al. In vivo ultrasonic measures of skin layer thicknesses at various body locations and postures[C]//Proceedings Volume 10580, Medical Imaging 2018:Ultrasonic Imaging and Tomography. Houston:SPIE, 2018:105801B.
[13] GHAZY A, BERGSTROM D J. Influence of the air gap between protective clothing and skin on clothing performance during flash fire exposure[J]. Heat and Mass Transfer, 2011, 47(10):1275-1288.
[14] FRANKMAN D, WEBB B W, BUTLER B W, et al. Measurements of convective and radiative heating in wildland fires[J]. International Journal of Wildland Fire, 2013, 22(2):157-167.
[15] LI J, TIAN M. Personal thermal protection simulation under diverse wind speeds based on life-size manikin exposed to flash fire[J]. Applied Thermal Engineering, 2016, 103:1381-1389.